Filers who named this exact article number in their own text. It is their sentence, not our reading — and not a causal claim.
| Who | Country | What they wrote |
|---|---|---|
| ANITEC-ASSINFORM | IT | ially, in theory, reveal something sensitive about them. This focus on merely theoretical sensitivity also conflicts the goals of Art. 9 ‐ to protect fundamental rights and freedoms, including by preventing discrimination. What is responsive to that goal ↗ |
| Asociación Española de Economía Digital (Adigital) | ES | of data for the above purpose (most likely). In the case of the latter, it will be important to understand what Art. 9(2) GDPR condition will be considered appropriate by the DPAs for this purpose. ● DSA: ○ Interplay between Art. 16 DSA and the GDPR. Recital 5 ↗ |
| European Centre for Certification and Privacy (ECCP) | LU | hird-party beneficiaries. Secondary use of personal data for medical research purposes Current legislative framework According to Article 9 GDPR, personal data concerning health is considered a special category of personal data that cannot be processed unless ↗ |
| Bitkom e.V. | DE | is term. Similarly, the legal basis for processing special categories of data (SCD) under Article 10 of the AI Act in relation to Article 9 GDPR remains unclear. Art. ↗ |
| Confederation of Swedish Enterprise | SE | of any theoretical possibility of identifying a sensitive trait. Processing of SCD is prohibited, unless any of the exemptions in Art. 9 GDPR is applicable (e.g. that the data subject explicitly consents to the processing, the processing is necessary for the e ↗ |
| AMICE - Association of Mutual Insurers and Insurance Cooperatives in Europe | BE | e possibility to implement new legal basis for health data processing. Therefore, by introducing a new additional exception under Article 9(2) would foster harmonisation and legal clarity. 5 II. The impact of the GDPR on AI and innovation The GDPR is a technol ↗ |
| ACCIS | BE | l data (preventing fraud and the safety of the banking system) shall be deemed as a substantial public interest in the meaning of Article 9(2)(g) of GDPR7. 3. Ineffectiveness of specific EDPB Guidelines. ↗ |
| Fonds Soziales Wien | AT | personenbezogener Daten nur die ausdrückliche Einwilligung gem. Art 9 Abs 2 lit a DSGVO als mögliche Rechtsgrundlage. Gerade bei niederschwelligen sozialen Leistungen (zB Notquartiere für wohnungslose Personen oder Straßensozialarbeit) gestaltet sich dies alle ↗ |
| University of Padova | IT | vorire la libertà della ricerca scientifica: a) una base giuridica espressamente dedicata al trattamento dei dati c.d. sensibili (art. 9, par. ↗ |
| Bundessteuerberaterkammer | DE | msetzung der DSGVO durch die Mitglied- staaten oder der Verwendung fakultativer Spezifikationsklauseln wie Artikel 8 Absatz 1 und Artikel 9 Absatz 4 DSGVO). Keine Angaben b. Bitte benennen Sie konkret, in welchem Bereich Ihrer Meinung nach eine Fragmen- tierun ↗ |
| FEBIS | DE | convictions and offences, that cannot be processed occurring the same kind of exemptions set forth in article 9. We suggest a rethinking of this approach, maybe by introducing some exemptions in article 10, as it has been done in article 9, especially in relat ↗ |
| Confederation of European Security Services (CoESS) | BE | content if it is of substantial public interest, on the basis of Union or Member State law, as per Article 9.1.g. 3 Catherine PIANA, Director General CoESS | Confederation of European Security Services Avenue des Arts | Kunstlaan 56 | B-1000 Brussels | Belgium ↗ |
| Unipol Gruppo | IT | e legal certainty, Unipol invites the Commission to include in its recommendations the inclusion of an additional exception under Article 9(2) of the GDPR to allow data controllers to process Special Data closely linked to the activation and performance of a c ↗ |
| German Insurance Association | DE | Poland, Slovakia and Spain have corresponding special regulations. Some of these regulations are based on Art. 9 (2) (b), (g) or (h) of the GDPR, or they are based on Art. 9 (4) of the GDPR. In part, they are also understood as specification of Art. 9 (2) (f) ↗ |
| BDI e.V. (Federation of German Industries) | DE | persons and of services. The interpretation of the legal basis for processing differs. Special categories of data (as provided in Article 9(4) of GDPR) must be highlighted as potentially creating a situation where companies would apply the highest common denom ↗ |
| Bundesvereinigung der Deutschen Arbeitgeberverbände | DE | r (Religionszugehörigkeit) als auch Gesundheitsdaten (Arbeitsunfähigkeits-Bescheinigungen) besondere personenbezogene Daten gemäß Art. 9 Abs. 1 DS-GVO darstellen. Um die Belastung, welche die Erstellung eines Verzeichnisses über Verarbeitungstätigkeiten vor al ↗ |
| Chalmers University of Technology | SE | that can be processed. News websites might fall in the category of sites revealing information about special categories of data (Article 9(1) GDPR), since reading about certain topics could reveal one’s political opinion or health status (see Wesselkamp et al ↗ |
| EDRi European Digital Rights | ES | services, in ways that threaten fundamental rights to data protection, privacy and more. For example, the legal basis of consent (Article 9.(2)(a)) has frequently been used to justify the implementation of biometric surveillance systems, despite the fact that ↗ |
| Selbstregulierung Informationswirtschaft e.V. (SRIW) | DE | lenge remains on determining the legal basis for granting users access under Art. 6 GDPR; where sensitive data might be affected, Art. 9 GDPR must be respected, too. It is important to note that the GDPR takes precedence over the Data Act (Art. 1 (5) Data Act, ↗ |
| BSA | The Software Alliance | BE | ll create a specific and additional condition for processing or whether providers of high-risk AI systems will have to rely on an Article 9(2) of the GDPR regarding processing of special categories of data for the above purpose. In the case of the latter, it w ↗ |
| Danske Universiteter | DK | , at bestemte typer af forskningsdata vanskeligt kan deles, f.eks. fordi en medlemsstat ikke har udnyttet det nationale råderum i artikel 9, stk. 2, litra j, og der dermed ikke er etableret et behandlingsgrundlag, som kan sikre, at visse typer af forskningsdat ↗ |
| Information Accountability Foundation | US | ct to necessity and proportionally considerations. A new condition for using special categories of data should also be created in Article 9. A number of US State Privacy laws, for example the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA), contain a provision exempting ↗ |
| Oplysningsforbundet May Day | DK | g således er transaktionen per definition identificeret. Det har derfor betydning, hvilke personoplysninger der behandles. Her er artikel 9 i GDPR udtømmende og omfatter bl.a. biometriske data. Det forhold, at biometriske data ligger på en 3. parts server (Ser ↗ |
| Association 0D | FR | sollicitations). Enfin, de manière très opérationnelle, la notion de « catégorie particulière de données à caractère personnel » (art.9) est appliquée avec de fortes lacunes dès qu’il s’agit des forces de sécurité intérieures (ex : des agents de police non « s ↗ |
| United Internet | DE | of the GDPR and enforcing data subject rights under Art. 12 ff of the GDPR, especially in the processing of sensitive data under Art. 9 GDPR, remain key considerations. On the other hand, the sensible use of AI, for example, in supporting cybersecurity measur ↗ |
| European Blood Alliance (EBA) | NL | l basis of processing where the aim of the processing is linked to the processing of special category personal data as defined in Article 9 (1), balanced against the ability to process that same data lawfully, (in accordance with either Article 9(2)(h) or 9(2) ↗ |
| Insurance Europe | BE | hat the processing of health data necessary for this purpose is covered by one of the derogations in the GDPR, such as the one in Art. 9 (2) (f). Each topic is further elaborated in the sections below. ↗ |
| VNO-NCW / MKB Nederland | NL | lt in a risk to the rights and freedoms of data subjects, or the processing includes special categories of data as referred to in Article 9(1) or personal data relating to criminal convictions and offences referred to in Article 10, an enterprise or an organiz ↗ |
| Avvocato | IT | sempre agevole interazione tra quelle previste per tutti i dati personali (art. 6) e quelle per le particolari categorie di dati (art. 9), mediante un maggiore loro allineamento. E' in ogni caso necessario, sic stantibus rebus, che sia precisato che le ipotesi ↗ |
| Federation of Austrian Industries | AT | tion Impact Assessment for high risks, etc.)? Company A: “We process data of data subjects in the field of credit rating, but not Art 9 GDPR-data. The data processed poses a certain risk to the data subject, but usually not a high risk in this context. ↗ |
Source: public consultation submissions and position papers. n = 58 mentions; counted as a literal reference to the article number.